image3 (1)
One of several little castles in the region

In 1953, residents in southern France voted to change their town’s name from Castillon-sur-Dordogne (‘Little Castle-on-the-Dordogne River’) to Castillon-la-Bataille, or ‘Little-Castle-of-the-Battle.’  This wasn’t just some plucky whim to add drama to their heritage. Exactly five hundred years earlier, their hometown had hosted a battle with pedigree – the final fight of the 100 Years War. During this tournament of maim and kill, England’s eighty-year-old Earl of Shrewsbury was pinned down by his slain horse and bludgeoned to death by an axe-wielding French soldier. This ended not just a battle, but the protracted war.

Elisabeth and Eric at Château La Rose Poncet

The more I learn about the ‘100 Years War’ between France and England, the more the name appears to have been invented by an enthusiastic, though erroneous, teacher trying to simplify history for impatient, bored students. First, this ‘war’ lasted not 100 years, but 116 years. Second, it was not a war but a series of battles and skirmishes, only loosely connected in purpose. Third, this ‘war’ was preceded and succeeded by ample other conflicts between France and England. Slapping this moniker on is like a historian considering US conflicts in Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan as being part of ‘The 65 Year War’ between the US and, well, Asia.

The grounds of La Rose Poncet – ready for harvest

A big surprise about this battle? It was residents of Bordeaux themselves – the ‘Bordelais’ – who requested that Henry VI of England send in troops to rescue them from the French. Truly. Bordeaux, and a sizable chunk of the land mass we now call France, had then been under English reign for hundreds of years. The residents of Bordeaux were more interested in maintaining their flourishing, prosperous, wine trade with England and sunning themselves in the Aquitaine sun than having estranged neighbors gallop in uninvited to hoist an alien flag over their home territory.

The weekend before last, alerted by another American wine blog writer living in Bordeaux named Alex Rychlewski, I visited ‘Portes Ouvertes’ in the wine region known as ‘Castillon – Côtes de Bordeaux.’ This region sits on the right bank of the Gironde estuary, bordering the more famed (and expensive) Saint Emilion wine region to the west.

Château Pitray - home to the same family for 6 centuries
Château Pitray – home to generations of the same family for six centuries

For two days, the owners of seventeen wine châteaux threw open doors, uncorked bottles, and poured out streams of their prized products. I managed to GPS navigate through forests and over hills, wending a route to track down ten châteaux (ranging from stately castles to garages).

The first château I visited was the 12 hectare (30 acre) Belgian owned Château Goubau. After I parked, Bea Goubau-Goossens trekked off into vines to implore her husband Stéphane to dismount his tractor and come pour wine for the early bird visitor – me – all bright-eyed and enthused for a morning tasting – degustacion – at 10.15 am (well I did have the afternoon already planned out). After dismounting his tractor, Stéphane appeared as well dressed as though on his way to a wedding – minus the jacket. Their wines? Their top red wines are peppery, with a beautiful balance between tannins and fruit.

Gentle hills and quiet living

This was an excellent start to the journey – where good quality wine results from careful vine keeping and thoughtful investments in appropriate technology. Fermentation takes place in horizontal steel tanks where a rotating arm (along the eye-level axis) accomplishes the same as a ‘pump over’ or ‘push down’ to keep floating grape skins in constant contact with juice. Why this method? Because it is gentle on the grapes, Stéphane said. The non-traumatic consideration toward grapes is a factor he constantly keeps in mind to produce quality wines. Considering Stéphane has an MBA from Harvard and ten years winemaking experience, I was not surprised to find him well-organized, methodical, and determined to produce the best. The couple moved here in the year 2005 to a site with a stunning vista of lower woodlands, because “we had a passion,” Stéphane admits. When I departed, having invested in a few bottles of their wine, Bea reminded me how the wine “goes particularly well with food.”

Very true.

image1 (6)
Lunch time picnic spread near the vines

At the next château – far more rickety – the owner’s friends had set up an ancient film projector inside. They wooed me in, glass in hand, to a dank stone cellar to watch a black-and-white newsreel of skirted London ladies parading around the 1966 World Trade Fair.

Newsreel showtime in a cellar

This was followed by a quick snippet about communist elections in bygone France. The relation to wine? None. Yet it was intriguing, especially for a community steeped in a history that revolves around England and power. I tipped my glass, bid adieu, and motored on.

Next? Lunch in a garden (which was excellent), where the owner’s young son insisted that I halt mid-way through a plate of roasted duck to attend his magic show in the garage. Which, of course, it would have been impolite to refuse. This day was getting more intriguing by the minute.

At Château La Rose Poncet, proprietors Elisabeth and Eric shared their stories about grunts and grief and eventual gratitude at their making wine for over 15 years. They take particular pride in their ‘Mon anGe’ wine (which is a play on names of their children), a prize-winning 100 percent Merlot. The wine was well made and their dedication to the vines was obvious.


At Château Lapeyronie, we sampled a delightful 100 percent Carménère – a definite unexpected and beautiful highlight of this foray into Castillon.

image1 (1)
Life is good

Our final stop was at Château Fontbaude – which involved sitting at a table in the shade of trees with Christian, one of the owners, to sample his 100 percent Merlot from an 80-year-old plot. This was a peaceful way to end the day.

And the wine from this region – in general?

Growers tell how their vineyards share identical or similar geology to neighboring Saint Emilion. The red wines are primarily made from Merlot (several of them 100 percent) and Cabernet Franc (or Malbec), while Cabernet Sauvignon is little used. Whether oaked in barrels or not, many wines are mouth-puckeringly tannic, which may relate to the purity of the limestone substrate. The dichotomy here – including pitfalls and advantages – is that small growers often disregard investing time or expense in improving production techniques, while those winemakers who do so often produce excellent wines at reasonable costs.

image1 (5)
Unexpected surprise – 100 percent Carménère

Of the many wines we tasted, the following deserve ranking as good, excellent, and superlative values for price (which, as my friend Annabelle explained in French, is: ‘bon rapport, qualité prix’) using the proprietary Vino Value algorithm. *


Vino Value™ Scoring of Selected Red Wines –

Castillon – Côtes de Bordeaux

Wine Retail Price – Euros Retail Price – US Dollars Equivalent Value Score
Château Goubau ‘La Source’ 2012 € 12.50 $14.00 Excellent Value ♫♫
Château Goubau 2011 € 17.00 $19.04 Superlative Value ♫♫♫
Château de Laussac ‘Cuvée La Dame’ 2013 € 5.00 $5.60 Excellent Value ♫♫
Château de Laussac ‘Cuvée La Fleur’ 2012 € 8.00 $8.96 Superlative Value ♫♫♫
Château de Laussac (A.N. Robin) 2012 € 12.50 $14.00 Excellent Value ♫♫
Château de Laussac ‘Cuvée Sacha’ 2012 € 19.50 $21.84 Excellent Value ♫♫
[Château de Laussac ‘Les Valentines’ 2012 (Saint Émilion Grand Cru) ] € 15.00 $16.80 Excellent Value ♫♫
Château La Font du Jeu (Lapeyronie) 2012 € 7.00 $7.84 Superlative Value ♫♫♫
Château Lapeyronie 2012 € 9.00 $10.08 Good Value ♫
Château Lapeyronie 2012 (no sulfites) € 15.00 $16.80 Excellent Value ♫♫
Château Lapeyronie Carménère (100%) 2012 € 15.00 $16.80 Superlative Value ♫♫♫
Château Franc La Fleur 2011 € 10.00 $11.20 Good Value ♫
Château La Rose Poncet 2010 € 6.00 $6.72 Good Value ♫
Château La Rose Poncet ‘Vent d’Ange’ 2011 € 6.00 $6.72 Excellent Value ♫♫
Château La Rose Poncet 2011 € 8.00 $8.96 Good Value ♫
Château La Rose Poncet ‘Mon anGe’ 2011 € 20.00 $22.40 Good Value ♫
Château Bellevue – Danièle Hirtzlin 2012 € 6.00 $6.72 Excellent Value ♫♫
Château Bellevue – Danièle Hirtzlin ‘Vignobles Lydoire’ 2012 € 7.50 $8.40 Good Value ♫
Château Bellevue – Danièle Hirtzlin ‘Cé Ma Cuvée’ 2011 € 14.00 $15.68 Good Value ♫
Château de Belcier 2010 € 10.40 $11.65 Good Value ♫
Château de Belcier ‘Le Pins de Belcier’ € 14.40 $16.13 Good Value ♫
Clos Vedelago Merlot 2012 € 11.00 $12.32 Good Value ♫
Château Fontbaude ‘Vieilles Vignes’ 2012 € 10.00 $11.20 Good Value ♫
Château Fontbaude ‘L’Ame de Fontbaude’ 2011 € 16.00 $17.92 Good Value

* For more information on this proprietary wine value scoring algorithm,  click here.


Drone Footage from Blaye – Côtes de Bordeaux 

We leave beautiful Castillon now and return to the northeast (an hour-long drive) to home territory. I recently prepared this short video – including ample drone footage – for friends Jérôme and Valérie Eymas who own and manage Château La Rose Bellevue (Blaye – Côtes de Bordeaux wine appellation). The music ‘Le Bon Vin’ was generously provided free of copyright by the French musician/poet duo Philippe Lemoine and Hervé Tirefort (more information about them is on the YouTube site). And thanks to Les and Clarissa from Villa Saint Simon, Blaye, for introducing me to these winemakers.

Valérie wrote this about the video (which she directed) on her Facebook site:

DSC_0029Tom, Jérôme and I have worked on a little video this summer (Tom has done all the job!!!). Us, we put in all our talent, in lifting up our glass of wine several time under the bite of the sun & the 40°C (104°F) burning of the heat… We chose to illustrate this video with a French song & music made by Hervé Tirefort and Philippe Lemoine. Those who know us will find in the lyrics (sorry but it’s in French) our philosophy of Epicure. Life is short and we must not miss all the good things that Mother Nature offers to us. We turn our grapes in our winery into a nectar, another day we adore tasting a nice dish of fried porcini mushrooms that we picked ourselves early in the bushes, as well as a fruit tart that we’ve made with fruits that we’ve picked in our grandmother’s garden… Isn’t it the Good Life ???

Indeed, it is.

This Post Has 4 Comments

  1. Tom, I’m really enjoying discovering the hidden corners of Bordeaux through your eyes 🙂

    1. Thanks Chrissie (are you Mother Chrissie now?) – !

      Delighted you enjoy these local explorations. You must, and in time you will, visit, and I’ll give you a tour. Our homes are in France now, so we have time enough to explore each others’ wine territory during the coming years 🙂

      Hope you are in good form!

      Tom M.

      1. Not yet Tom, but any day now! Looking forward to getting stuck back into the wine scene and getting across to Bordeaux sometime !

        1. Cool. You’ll make an awesome Mama! And we’re neighbors so we’ll be sharing wine stories (and tastings) for years to come… 😉

Leave a Reply

Close Menu